top of page

Tax Preparer or Red Flag? How to Know Who You Can Trust

20 hours ago
4 min read

Written by: Abigail Ellis

Published on: 11/16/2026



It is your first time filing taxes on your own. Your friend says, “Go to my tax person. They get everybody huge refunds!”

Sounds great. Who does not want a bigger refund?

But then the preparer tells you they can “work some magic,” promises a specific refund before reviewing your information, and wants their fee taken from your refund without clearly explaining how much they are charging.

That is when you need to slow down.

Choosing someone to prepare your taxes is a bigger decision than it might seem. You are giving that person access to your Social Security number, income information, address, and possibly banking, education, and family information. More importantly, you are ultimately responsible for the information on your tax return, even when someone else prepares it. The IRS specifically recommends choosing a tax return preparer carefully for this reason.



First, Know Who You Are Hiring

Not every tax preparer has the same training or credentials. You may come across a CPA, or Certified Public Accountant, an Enrolled Agent, an attorney, or another paid tax return preparer.

Enrolled Agents are federally licensed tax professionals who meet IRS requirements and have unlimited rights to represent taxpayers before the IRS. CPAs and attorneys may also have unlimited representation rights, subject to their professional qualifications. Other preparers may have more limited authority to represent you if a tax problem comes up later.

That does not automatically mean you need the person with the fanciest title. A college student with one W-2 may have very different needs from someone running a business or earning income from several freelance jobs. The goal is to find someone qualified for your situation.


Before You Say Yes, Ask Questions

You are allowed to interview the person handling your taxes. In fact, you should.

Ask about:

  • Their credentials and experience. Have they worked with situations like yours?

  • Their PTIN. Anyone who is paid to prepare or substantially assist in preparing federal tax returns generally must have a valid Preparer Tax Identification Number.

  • Their fees. Ask what the service will cost and what could make that price increase.

  • How you can contact them later. Will they still be available after tax season if you receive a letter from the IRS?

  • How they protect your information. You are handing over extremely sensitive personal and financial information.

  • Whether they will explain your return. You should understand what you are signing.

The IRS also maintains a searchable directory of federal tax return preparers with certain credentials and qualifications. IRS Directory of Federal Tax Return Preparers



🚩 Know the Red Flags

Someone promising you a guaranteed huge refund should make you ask more questions. Be cautious if a preparer asks you to sign a blank or incomplete return, refuses to sign the return themselves, will not include their PTIN, bases their fee on a percentage of your refund, asks you to have your refund deposited into their personal account, or encourages you to claim income, expenses, credits, or deductions that are not true. The IRS specifically warns taxpayers about several of these practices.

And remember this sentence:

“Everybody does it” is not tax advice.

If something on your return does not make sense, ask about it before signing.


A College Student Scenario

Imagine you are in college. You worked at a restaurant and received a W-2, but you also made money doing photography and social media work on the side. You received a 1099 for some of that work, and your college sent you a 1098-T. Your roommate says, “Just use the person my family uses. They only charge $50.”

Price matters, especially when you are a student. But your first question should not be, “Who is cheapest?”

It should be, “Does this person understand my tax situation?”

Ask whether the preparer has experience with W-2 income, self-employment or 1099 income, business expenses, and education-related tax issues. A more complicated return may require someone with more experience than a simple W-2 return.


Before You Sign

Never treat your tax return like the terms and conditions on an app. Read it.

Check your name, Social Security number, income, filing status, dependents, bank information, and the major credits or deductions being claimed. Ask questions about anything you do not recognize. A legitimate professional should be able to explain what they did without making you feel embarrassed for asking. This connects directly to the Survival Program because becoming financially independent also means learning when to ask for professional help and how to recognize whether that help is trustworthy.


A good tax professional should not make taxes feel more secretive. They should help you understand what is happening. So do not choose someone simply because they promise the biggest refund, charge the lowest price, or somebody on social media calls them a “tax wizard.”


Check their qualifications. Ask about fees. Watch for red flags. Read before you sign. Keep a copy of your return. And remember it is your tax return, even when someone else prepares it.

Comments


At Step’s Foundation, Inc., we are committed to fostering a respectful and inclusive environment where individuals from all backgrounds are welcomed and valued. We recognize that the strength of our community lies in the richness of its diverse perspectives and lived experiences. Our work is grounded in the belief that collaboration across differences drives meaningful solutions and lasting impact. We strive to ensure that all individuals engaging with our organization, whether as team members, partners, or community members, feel heard, respected, and empowered.

 

Step’s Foundation, Inc. is an equal opportunity employer and welcomes the contributions of all who share in our mission to serve and uplift our community.

​


Step's Foundation, Inc. is registered with the State of Florida to solicit contributions #CH63432.  A COPY OF THE OFFICIAL REGISTRATION AND FINANCIAL INFORMATION MAY BE OBTAINED FROM THE DIVISION OF CONSUMER SERVICES BY CALLING TOLL-FREE (800-435-7352) WITHIN THE STATE. REGISTRATION DOES NOT IMPLY ENDORSEMENT, APPROVAL, OR RECOMMENDATION BY THE STATE.  Your gift is tax-deductible as allowed by law; Step's Foundation, Inc. is registered with the state under the Solicitation of Contributions Act.

407-279-0713

PO BOX 700625, Saint Cloud, FL 34770

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • TikTok
candid-seal-platinum-2023.png

© 2025 by Step's Foundation, Inc.

bottom of page